The challenges of research in the field of human dignity
-
Seyed Abdosaleh Jafari
,
Behin Araminia
,
Hanie Tavasoli
,
Nafiseh Tavasoli
,
Soheil Abedi
,
Ahmad Fayaz-Bakhsh
Abstract
|
Research on human dignity is crucial for understanding the ethical foundations of human rights. Neglecting to address certain pitfalls in this area of research can lead to adverse effects, including the perpetuation of discrimination, the misrepresentation of dignity across different schools of thought, and the weakening of ethical standards in human rights discourse. The present study aims to identify such challenges by analytically examining outstanding research in this field. Our surveys have identified challenges and pitfalls that were categorized into two groups: challenges in the field of materials, and challenges in the field of methods. In terms of materials, researchers may fail to adequately consider the historical and cultural contexts that shape these views, while in terms of methods, they may overlook the diverse perspectives that contribute to a comprehensive understanding of dignity. Consequently, it is imperative for researchers to remain vigilant and avoid these pitfalls to ensure that their work upholds the true essence of human dignity and effectively advocates for the rights of all individuals, especially those from marginalized backgrounds. |
Brannmark J. Respect for persons in bioethics: towards a human rights-based account. Human Rights Review. 2017;18(2):171-87.
Moka Mubelo W. Reconciling law and morality in human rights discourse .2017; p. 94-141.
Riley S. Human dignity: comparative and conceptual debates. International Journal of Law in context. 2010;6(2):117-38.
Vorster N. A theological perspective on human dignity, equality and freedom. Verbum et Ecclesia. 2012;33(1):1-6.
Autiero A. Human dignity in an ethical sense: basic considerations. Interdisciplinary Journal for Religion and Transformation in Contemporary Society. 2020;6:9-21.
Rothhaar M. Human dignity and human rights in bioethics: the Kantian approach. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy. 2010;13:251-7.
Braun R, Qigek HI. New approaches to human dignity in the context of Qur'anic anthropology. 2017.
Motahari M. Islam and the requirements of time. Qom: Sadr Publications. 1986;1:318-9.
Tabataba'i M. Tafsir al-Mizan. Tehran: World Organization of Islamic Services; 1982. P.10-5.
Almahfali M, Avery H. Human rights from an Islamic perspective: a critical review of Arabic peer-reviewed articles. Social Sciences. 2023;12(2):106.
Smith JI. Women in Islam: Equity, equality, and the search for the natural order. Journal of the American Academy of Religion. 1979;47(4):517-37.
Brown J. The fate of non-muslims: perspectives on salvation outside of Islam. Yaqeen Institute for Islamic Research. 2019.
Parrott J. Al-Ghazali and the golden rule: ethics of reciprocity in the works of a muslim sage. Journal of Religious & Theological Information. 2017;16(2):68-78.
Waldron J. What do the philosophers have against dignity? NYU School of Law, Public Law Research Paper. 2014:4-59.
Asghari S. Understanding human dignity in Shi’i Islam: debates, challenges, and solutions for contemporary issues. Religions. 2023;14(4):505.
Muir W. The life of Mahomet: Vol. 3: BoD–Books on Demand; 2022:74-75.
Jafari SA, Araminia B, Tavasoli H, Tavasoli N, Abedi S, Bakhshe AF. Examining the criteria of human dignity. Journal of Medical Ethics and History of Medicine. 2023;16.
Aldhebiani AY. Species concept and speciation. Saudi journal of biological sciences. 2018;25(3):437-40.
Kietzmann C. Aristotle on the definition of what it is to be human. Journal of Aristotle's anthropology. 2019:25-43.
Levis NA, Isdaner AJ, Pfennig DW. Morphological novelty emerges from pre-existing phenotypic plasticity. Nature ecology & evolution. 2018;2(8):1289-97.
Lewens T. Species natures: A critique of neo-aristotelian ethics. The Philosophical Quarterly. 2020;70(280):480-501.
Jafari S, Tavasoli N, Tavasoli H, Abedi S, Fayaz Bakhshe A, Araminia B. Contemplating on human dignity: Who counts as human? Journal of Medical Ethics and History of Medicine. 2024;17.
Jacobson N. A taxonomy of dignity: a grounded theory study. BMC International Health and Human Rights. 2009;9(1):3.
Peicius E, Urbonas G, Harrison WD, et al. Dignity violations and barriers to dignity assurance for terminally ill patients at the end of life: a cross-sectional analysis. Medicina (Kaunas). 2022;58(2).
Gluchman V. Nature of dignity and human dignity. Human Affairs. 2017;27(2):131-44.
Azinifar Q. Our Book. first ed. Tehran: Arvij; 2005; p.49.
Sullivan WM, Kymlicka W. Universal Islamic declaration of human rights. In: Sullivan WM, Kymlicka W, editors. The globalization of ethics: religious and secular perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2007. p. 247-56.
Sensen O. Kant on human dignity reconsidered. Kant-Studien. 2015;106(1):107-29.
Von der Pfordten D. On the dignity of man in Kant. Philosophy. 2009;84(3):371-91.
Johnson PR. An analysis of “dignity”. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics. 1998;19:337-52.
Sensen O. Human dignity in historical perspective: The contemporary and traditional paradigms. European journal of political theory. 2011;10(1):71-91.
Mozaffari MH. The concept of human dignity in the Islamic thought. Hekmat Quarterly Journal: International Journal of Academic Research. 2014;4:11-28.
Jafari SA, Araminia B, Tavasoli N, Tavasoli H, Abedi S, Navab SA, et al. The criterion of human dignity in the Quran. J Med Ethics Hist Med. 2024;17:2.
Dignity: A history. Debes R, editor: Oxford University Press; 2017 22 Jun 2017.
Debes R. Dignity. In: Zalta EN, Nodelman U, editors. the stanford encyclopedia of ohilosophy. 2023: etaphysics research lab, Stanford University; 2023.
McCrudden C. Human dignity and judicial interpretation of human rights. European Journal of International Law. 2008;19(4):655-724.
Thiel MJ. Chapitre 4. Human dignity: intrinsic or relative value? Journal international de bioethique. International Journal of Bioethics. 2010; 21:51-88.
Riley S. Human dignity and law: Legal and philosophical investigations: Routledge; 2017.
Muders S. Human dignity: final, inherent, absolute? Rivista di estetica. 2020(75):84-103.
Gilabert P, Gilabert P. Understanding human dignity in human rtights. Human Dignity and Human Rights: Oxford University Press; 2018. p. 113–40.
Machery E. Human nature. In: Smith DL. ed. How biology shapes philosophy: New Foundations for Naturalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2016. p. 204-26.
Samuels R. Science and human nature. Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement. 2012;70:1-28.
| Files | ||
| Issue | Vol 17 (2024) | |
| Section | Original Article(s) | |
| Keywords | ||
| Human dignity; Respect; Personhood; Human rights; Qualitative research; Bioethics. | ||
| Rights and permissions | |
|
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
