Compassion in Jewish, Christian and secular nursing. a systematic comparison of a key concept of nursing
(Part I )
Abstract
Background
The topos of the Compassionate God is a dominant motive of the Jewish and Christian traditions. It is relevant for nursing because it asks the nurse to imitate God so as to become God-like. Also, to think that God suffers with the suffering believers is thought to give comfort to them. Because in the western world the topos of the Compassionate God represents the basis of the ethics of compassion/caring, this piece of basic research is important for clinical practice. This study explores to what extent Jewish and Christian nursing adhered to the biblical topos of the Compassionate God at different periods and in different cultural contexts.
Method
A mixed methods approach was used. It included variations of hermeneutical text analysis as used in historical, philosophical, theological, science of religion, and nursing research.
Results
The analysis of the literary sources shows that the topos of the Compassionate God was interpreted differently in different cultural contexts. However, at all times it directed religious and secular nursing. Since the beginning of the 21st century it builds the core of "compassionate caring" as propagated by North American nursing science.
Conclusions
The topos of the Compassionate God laid the foundation of the tradition of the ethics of compassion in nursing. More research is required to learn whether it also plays a role in Islamic nursing.
Käppeli S. Vom Glaubenswerk zur Pflegewissenschaft, Geschichte des Mit-Leidens in der christlichen, jüdischen und
freiberuflichen Krankenpflege (The history of compassion in Christian, Jewish and secular nursing). Bern: Huber; 2004.
Die Bibel, Einheitsübersetzung, Altes und Neues Testament (The Bible, Unitary Translation. Old and New Testament). Stuttgart; 1998.
Maier J. Leiden und Weisheit in der jüdischen Mystik (Suffering and wisdom in Jewish mysticism). Leiden und Weisheit in der Mystik. Jaspert B. Paderborn; 1992.
Gadamer HG. Wahrheit und Methode (Truth and Method). Tübingen; 1980.
Steck OH. Exegese des Alten Testaments (Interpretation of the Old Testament). Neukirchen-Vluyn; 1993.
Grimm G.: Rezeptionsgeschichte (The history of reception). München; 1977.
Weder H. Hermeneutik (Hermeneutics). Zürich; 1989.
Neusner J. Method and meaning in ancient Judaism. Ann Arbor; 1981.
Stemberger G. Vom Umgang der Rabbinen mit der Bibel (The Rabbis dealing with the Bible). München; 1989.
Gaut D, Leininger M. Caring, the compassionate healer. New York; 1991.
Lampe G ed. A Pastristic Greek Lexicon, 2 Bde. Oxford; 1961 (PGL).
Levy J. Wörterbuch über die Talmudim und Midraschim (Dictionary for the Talmudim and Midraschim). Darmstadt; 1963.
Hornby AS. Oxford Advanced Learner's dictionary of Current English. Oxford; 1980.
Talmud, der babylonische, 12 Bde., 2. ed., translated by Goldschmidt L. Berlin; 1966.
Tertullian: Ausgewählte Schriften, private und katechetische Schriften (Selected writings). Bd. 1, mit Lebensabriss und
Einleitungen (with biography and introduction), Kellner KA, ed. BKV Bd. 7, Bardenhewer O, Scherman T, Weyman K, eds.
Kempten/München; 1912: 215-219.
Cyprianus: Des heiligen Kirchenvaters Caecilius Cyprianus sämtliche Schriften (The complete writings of the holy church father Caesilius Cyprianus), Bd. 2, Briefe, Bd. 2, BKV Bd. 60, Bardenhewer O, Schermann T, Weyman K, eds. Kempten/München; 1928:83-124.
Basilius: Des heiligen Kirchenlehrers Basilius des Grossen ausgewählte Schriften (Selected writings of the holy church father Basilius the Great), Bd. 1, Letter to the Bishops of Italy and Gallia, BKV Bd. 46, Bardenhewer O, Schermann T, Weyman K, eds. Kempten/München; 1925: 135-140; 165-174.
Basilius: Des heiligen Kirchenlehrers Basilius des Grossen ausgewählte Schriften (Selected writings of the holy church father Basilius the Great), Bd. 2, Letter to the church of Antiochia, 4th sermon for the martyr Julitta, BKV Bd. 47, Bardenhewer O, Schermann T, Weyman K, eds. Kempten/München; 1925: 222f.
Gregor von Nyssa: Des heiligen Bischofs Gregor von Nyssa Schriften (The writings of the holy bishop Gregor of Nyssa). 5th speech, BKV Bd. 56, Bardenhewer O, Schermann T, Weyman K, eds. Kempten/München; 1927: 199-206.
Gregor von Nazianz: Des heiligen Gregor von Nazianz Reden (14th speech, About the love for the poor), Bd. 1, Haeuser P, ed. BKV Bd. 59, Bardenhewer O, Schermann T, Weyman K, eds. Kempten/München; 1928: 273-308.
Chrysostomos: Des heiligen Kirchenlehrers Johannes Chrysostomos Erzbischofs von Konstantinopel Kommentar zu den Briefen des heiligen Paulus an die Philipper und Kolosser (Commentary to the letters of Saint Paul for the people of Philippi and Kolossos by the holy church father John Chrysostomos). Bd. 7, 5. Homilie § 4, BKV, Bardenhewer O, Schermann T, Weyman K, eds. Kempten/München; 1924: 65-71.
Midrasch Schemot Rabba, allegorische Auslegung des zweiten Buches Mose (allegorical interpretation of the second book of Moise), Fürst J, Straschun O, eds. Bibliotheca Rabbinica, eine Sammlung alter Midraschim (a collection of ancient Midrashim), dr. Wünsche A., Hildesheim, 1967.
Midrasch TanhumaB, R. Tanhuma über die Tora, genannt Midrasch Jelammedenu (Tanhuma about the Tora, called Midrash Jelammedenu), 2 Bd., Bietenhard H, ed. JudChr, Bd 5/6, Lauer S, Thoma C, eds. Bern; 1980.
Midrasch Wajikra Rabba, haggadische Auslegung des 3. Buches Mose (haggadic interpretation of the 3. book of Moise), Fürst J, ed. Bibliotheca Rabbinica, Bd. 5, Hildesheim, 1969.
Mischna (transl.). Baneth E, Hoffmann D, Petuchowski M, Samter A et al. Berlin; 1924-1933.
Sifre on Deuteronomy, The Jewish Theological Seminary of America. New York; 1969.
Mekilta de Rabbi Ishmael, Lauterbach JZ, ed. 3 vol. Philadelphia; 1933-1935.
| Files | ||
| Issue | Vol 1 (2008) | |
| Section | Articles | |
| Keywords | ||
| Compassion, Caring, Religious and secular nursing, Nursing ethics. | ||
| Rights and permissions | |
|
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
